Phone vs 360 camera vs DSLR for HDRIs
Updated
All three can make a usable HDRI. A DSLR on a panoramic head gives the best quality, a 360 camera is the fastest, and a phone is the one you already have in your pocket.
| iPhone + HDRI Studio | 360 camera | DSLR + pano head | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extra gear | None, the phone you have | A 360 camera | Camera, wide lens, tripod and panoramic head |
| Capture | Handheld, guided, 18 or 26 positions | A few shots, both lenses at once | Many shots, manual |
| Stitching | Done for you online | In the camera or its app | Separate software (e.g. PTGui, Hugin) |
| Resolution | 4K or 8K EXR | Depends on the model | Highest |
| Close objects | Small seams under ~1.5 m | Fine | Clean with a nodal head |
| Best for | Lighting and reflections, on the spot | Fast captures | Hero backplates, top quality |
Phone
The app walks you around 18 or 26 dots, shoots up to 8 RAW brackets at each and adds a ground photo, then the service turns them into a 32-bit EXR. It's the quickest way from "I like the light here" to a file in Blender. The trade-off: you're turning by hand, so objects closer than about 1.5 m can show small seams. Choosing between phone apps? See HDRI apps for iPhone compared.
360 camera
Two back-to-back fisheye lenses see the whole sphere at once, so a capture is fast and close objects are not a problem. Dynamic range and resolution depend a lot on the model and whether it can bracket.
DSLR on a panoramic head
The standard for professional HDRIs: a nodal head removes parallax and a big sensor gives the cleanest, sharpest result. It's also the most gear, the most time on site and the most work afterwards. See how Poly Haven does it, step by step.
Questions
What is the cheapest way to make an HDRI?
Using a phone you already own. HDRI Studio is a free download with 2 free renders; after that a 4K render is $2.99 (US price).
Is a phone HDRI good enough for lighting?
For lighting and reflections, yes: it captures the real colour and brightness of the place in 32-bit float. Where a phone loses to a camera on a panoramic head is very close objects and the very highest resolutions for backgrounds.
Do I need a chrome ball?
No. A chrome ball gives a low-resolution, distorted view with you in the middle of it. A guided phone capture shoots the scene directly, at 4K or 8K.